MENTAL

39

WELFARE

Recent Penal Legislation in Relation

to

By H. K. SNELL, M.D. Officer, H.M. Prison, Liverpool The new scientific approach to the problem of the criminal may perhaps be said to date from the war period, but one of the most important measures foretelling the change in opinion which was to follow later, was the Mental Deficiency Act of 1913. This (in Sections 8 and 9) involved the recognition of a partial lack of responsibility in the mentally defective individual who committed Medical

crime.

a

By

the

of this Act, means were afforded whereby our prisons were of the mental defective who manifestly should not be committed In passing, we might note that the incidence of crime among mental

passing

freed from the

prison.

to

care

In 1935 there were 401 not as high as is sometimes suggested. of offences who were found criminal dealt with as mental defectives. persons guilty This represents only 1 in 290 of the total number of defectives reported. At

defectives is

Liverpool last year, out of a total of 3,591 receptions, 20 reported to the Courts as mental defectives and it was only three cases under Section 9. The borderline case, that

defect, presents

a

falling

between

normality

greater problem. In Law they

for their crimes and

they

constitute

a

are

not

remand

prisoners

were

necessary to deal with and certifiable mental excused

responsibility prison

inconsiderable number of

not

It is no easy task to advise as they do that of the general populace. their treatment and disposal. Evidence that a delinquent is of subnormal mentality, but not certifiable as a defective, does not, in practice, greatly assist an adjudicator although it may give him a better understanding of the individual But are there before him. I have been asked, when giving such evidence,

population, to

as

"

"

thousands of such cases? childhood this is provided to

not

centres

These a

patients

great

reach

guidance and training. During special schools and the training

to carry it on into adolescence. controversial always point as to whether seeded out among the general prison population.

of the Mental Welfare Associations

When

need

extent in

it has been

help

prison they they should be segregated or If segregated some measure of special treatment may be afforded them, but the way is then opened and underlined for them to regard themselves as mental cases and different from their fellows. This is to be avoided, especially in prison practice. In placing them among normal prisoners they are at a disadvantage and also constitute a drag on their fellows and in some cases may become a *

Address

(abridged) given

February, 1939.

at

a

Conference of Association of Mental Health Workers, Chester.

Published with the permission of H. M. Prison Commissioners though it does necessarily represent their viezvs.

not

40

MENTAL WELFARE

subject of ridicule. The nearer a case is to normal the better will he react to prison routine and the wiser and usual method is to place such patients in the ordinary prison, where a watchful but unobtrusive eye can be kept on their conduct and progress; but the lower grades are best dealt with under special conditions where they do not have to compete on equal terms with their fellow prisoners. (In this respect temperamental abnormalities are of more importance than intelligential defects.) The subnormal offender should, if possible, be dealt with by probation?supervision and guidance being the immediate need?and co-operation between probation officers and mental welfare workers would seem to offer the most hopeful opportunity of achieving this end. As with his normal brother so with the subnormal delinquent, when he does not respond to probation, Borstal treatment is usually resorted to and special facilities obtain for dealing with these cases. The trend of legislation is to avoid imprisonment for all young persons and a growing tendency to send more subnormals to Borstal is being manifested because of the difficulty of dealing with them by other methods when they have failed to respond to probation. The

compulsory centres, proposed by required to attend in

offender would be

the Criminal Justice Bill, which a young his leisure time, e.g., half-holidays and

may prove a successful alternative to short terms of imprisonment, the residential institutions, which are to be called Howard Houses. may

evenings, May as

to

I remind you that before

his fitness

to

undergo

and

a

lad is

profit

sent to

from the

Borstal he is

medically

as

examined

and reports are obtained and the Police; these are carefully

training,

from his parents, his school, employers, considered together with a home report, if available, prior to any recommendation being made to the Court. The number of Borstal Institutions is growing with some rapidity and before a youth is allocated to a particular Institution he is

psychologically and full regard paid to the circumstances of his case that he may be sent to the Borstal best likely to suit his individual requirements. Throughout training, stress is laid on this individuality and the inmate's particular difficulties are studied so that he may be suitably guided and advised. examined

so

This is the medical point of view, which emphasises the importance of individual treatment for the mentally ill-balanced person whether he be criminal or not, and it differs from the legal viewpoint which is concerned primarily with

public protection. It is, nevertheless, correct to say that the medical outlook is influencing legislation increasingly and is altering the attitude of the Courts to offenders when they are satisfied that some form of psychological or psychiatric treatment is desirable. a cases of simple subnormal mentality large number of delinquents exhibit emotional and temperamental abnormalities with varying degrees of mental instability. It is to be expected that a proportion of these, as they leave adolescence behind, will become stabilised and the training

In addition to

adolescent

MENTAL WELFARE and the

41

directed

guidance which they receive in the institution psychological treatment, as such, is not, however, always, necessary adjunct to the training of the adolescent offender.

psychologically

assists to this end. Actual nor

in fact

usually,

Offences due

a

to

mental defect and those which result from

immaturity

of

character formation and

irregular development of the natural instincts must, be therefore, carefully distinguished. While the Mental Deficiency Acts provide for the action to be followed in the case of the former the latter must be dealt with in a more expectant manner, and treatment should be directed towards training and instruction, with supervision. In some cases this is best undertaken under institutional conditions such as obtain at Borstal whereas in others the less rigid control of probation may suffice. Prolonged and skilled observation may be necessary to determine whether mere delayed character development, with failure in the formation of inhibitions, is the causative factor in the production of the antisocial conduct and whether the condition will prove transient, and social adaptation follow stabilisation once adolescence is safely passed. When such irregular development persists into adult life we are faced with forms of mental instability which frequently lead the individual into repeated conflicts with the law owing to his inability to maintain obedience to the social conventions. He then becomes at once the bane of the legislator and prison administrator. His abnormalities are insufficient to justify his permanent segregation and, although his intentions are often higher than his actions, he is unable to exercise the necessary self-control for long at a time. The result is that he becomes another recruit to the recidivist ranks. Exhortation and persuasion by a sympathetic observer do assist in keeping him on the rails for a while but usually fail to have a

permanent effect; in

a

few cases, however, where there

mental conflicts and socialise this class of

are

repressions, deeper psychological may help offender. Legislation hopes to ensure improved opportunities for the diagnosis of these conditions in offenders. Special remand homes are contemplated for the observation of problem cases under 17 years of age and arrangements are treatment

to

provision of reports from skilled investigators in older cases not remanded to prison. It must, however, be emphasised that sometimes a lengthy period of observation, noting the degree of response to discipline and training, may be necessary before a real decision can be established regarding the true nature of the symptoms under discussion. An accurate picture of the home life and environmental circumstances of the patient is, of course, also a requisite for accurate diagnosis. The natural outcome of focussing attention on the treatment of offenders is an increased interest in the prevention of crime and there is reason to hope that the Child Guidance Clinics help to prevent the problem child of to-day becoming the criminal of to-morrow. suggested

Now

for the

we

definition of

come

I do not propose to discuss the legal of fitness to plead. Suffice it to say that

to the insane offender.

insanity,

or

the

question

MENTAL WELFARE

42 all who have to

assist in the

to

the individual does

that the

tendency

is to

apply

the

least agree thai hardship and I think it is correct to add criteria of insanity less rigidly.

of these

working

not occur

in

matters at

practice,

legal

Close 011 three thousand men and women are remanded to prison each year for reports as to their states of mind; of these nearly 300 are found to be insane and dealt with at the Courts. At Courts of Summary Jurisdiction, where the medical view of insanity is ordinarily accepted, it is usual in cases of lesser crime, where medical evidence of unsoundness of mind has been given, for steps to be taken to

the detention of the accused in

ensure

a

mental

hospital.

the power of the Court in the case of the certifiable mental to make an order for him to be dealt with as a mental defective. If an offender is certifiable as insane, a Court of Summary Jurisdiction in England and Wales has no similar power. Clause 30 of the new Bill proposes to enable such Courts to make an order for the treatment of an offender who I*have referred

to

defective, under existing law

is certifiable

as

insane in the

same

way

as

they

can

at

present make

an

order

for the treatment of an offender who is mentally defective. Cases of insanity among prisoners serving sentences are, of course, certified by two medical men and two magistrates and removed, by order of the Secretary of State,

to a

mental

hospital.

As with mental deficiency, so here, the real problem arises with the borderline cases, the incipient and undeveloped psychotic. The practice of the Courts in asking for reports meets the necessity as regards those cases remanded in custody and now if the Court omits to request a report the Prison Medical Officer always makes it aware of such medical matters as he thinks should be brought to its notice.

The Bill before Parliament proposes to make some provision for Courts of to obtain a medical report on the mental condition of an offender who is not remanded to prison in order to assist the Court in deciding how to deal with him. Clause 38 will enable the Court to remand an offender on

Summary Jurisdiction

a requirement that he submits himself to medical examination, and for the payment of the cost of mental examinations at approved institutions or by approved persons.

bail with

provides

The importance of recognising such cases of non-certifiable mental abnormality and the possibility of their treatment by special methods has been appreciated by the Prison Medical Authorities and during the last four years an investigation into the psychological treatment of selected cases has been in progress This was instituted in an endeavour to form a frank and unbiased valuation of such treatment. A psychotherapist was attached to the prison and possible cases for treatment have been selected from time to time by Medical Officers at various prisons and Borstal Institutions throughout at Wormwood Scrubs Prison.

the country and transferred. We are now awaiting with interest the report which is being prepared. In estimating the success or failure of such treatment a

43

MENTAL WELFARE

after history and follow-up is indispensable. Unless this is obtained from reliable sources but little regard can be paid to apparent successes. It is

thorough

fortunate that in many of the prison cases the follow-up has been carried out by the Central Association for Mental Welfare. Certain facts are already accepted?

perhaps the most striking among which is that the number of cases to whom psychotherapy is applicable is relatively small.* Apart from those considered suitable for intensive psychotherapy there exists a number of cases of minor abnormality, the temporarily mal-adjusted and the like, who benefit very appreciably from psychotherapic conversations. In prison, close attention is given to such patients with, I think, a not inconsiderable degree of success. In addition to repeated interviews with the doctors they undoubtedly derive benefit from the regular life and peaceful atmosphere of the mental observation ward. Such improvement is particularly to be seen in certain remand cases. Temporary depression due to domestic or other difficulties, and some anxiety states are among those which often show a response to these conditions. Cases of sexual offences are notoriously difficult to treat, but others, in whom the offences are associated with some sexual difficulty as a contributory or underlying cause, may be encouraged to an understanding of their condition. These patients frequently require supervision for a lengthy period of time on release. Sometimes the Court will accept suggestions in the case of remand prisoners and deal with them in such a manner that the necessary supervision is obtained. The frequent difficulty is, who is to do the supervising. The Criminal

Bill

recognises the existence of offenders who, though mentally defective, are suffering from some form of mental illness or abnormality which may be susceptible to treatment. Clause 19 provides that probation orders may include a provision requiring such persons to not certifiable

as

Justice

insane

submit themselves

to

or

mental treatment and the Bill further enables payment as part of the expenses of probation committees.

to be made for such treatment

psychiatrist has now been extended beyond the confines of hospital and I suggest that the sphere of action of the Prison Medical Officer might likewise be enlarged. It is not infrequently suggested that prison is not the proper place for psychological investigation and that the doctor, by reason of his official position, is unlikely to receive the confidence and the co-operation of the prisoner. While obviously there will be exceptions I think it can be said, without hesitation, that the Prison Medical Officer does obtain the confidence of the majority of his patients and that often the prisoner, finding in him his first opportunity of discussing his difficulties with a sympathetic and understanding listener, is ready to accept the advice and treatment offered him. There is one point the value of which, perhaps, is not fully appreciated and it is that just because the Medical Officer is an official the prisoner regards him to some extent impartially and The orbit of the

the mental

*

As the Report has now been published and is reviewed references to it which here followed, are omitted.?Ed.

on

page 55, Dr. Swell's further

44

MENTAL WELFARE

does not expect to meet him outside in the future. I am speaking here more of remand cases. The patient in these circumstances may discuss matters which he might otherwise conceal and often is prepared to accept advice of a personal nature which in other circumstances it would be hard for him to do.

particularly

I

firmly

a

world of

believe that sometimes

a

little

plain speaking

and

straight talking

does

good.

A scheme in which a clinic could be run in connection with the prison and perhaps staffed by the prison Medical Officer might prove to be of benefit in

dealing with some cases after they leave prison. This could be worked up to bring about an increased co-operation between the probation officer, the mental health worker and the doctor with resultant benefit to the mental health of the non-certifiable offender. It might at least save some of them from committing

repeated

crimes and

returning regularly

Criminal conduct is is

correct

to

prison.

necessarily dependent on mental abnormality. A requirement in these matters; the safe-breaker who, wrist, asked me whether the X-ray apparatus would

not

first

perspective was X-raying his be any use for busting peters did not fall into the abnormal group. He was a physically fit man of average intelligence who deliberately chose this method of livelihood and he and his partners had a business arrangement whereby their families were cared for while they were in prison. He said he expected to serve approximately 3 years in 4, in prison and was prepared to do so. Norwood East has stated "To ensure permanent advantage from medical methods of attack the approval of legal, medical and public opinion is necessary ", and he points to the satisfactory working of the Mental Deficiency Acts and the public support for the compulsory detention of defectives who have committed crime as being due largely to the fact that the medical principles relating to mental deficiency are held to be satisfactory. The importance of this fundamental principle must be remembered in discussing the scientific treatment of crime, and he goes on to say No progress can be expected in this direction unless the judicial and administrative authorities, and the public are satisfied that modern therapy can be relied upon to produce beneficial results in certain cases of crime." when I

"

a

"

"

To suggest that all criminals require psychological treatment is but to undercause of those who are in real need of it and likely to respond to it. Further it has been put forward by some that all offenders, including first offenders mine the

?however trivial their offences?should be subjected to compulsory psychological investigation, the investigator having the power to detain the subject pending the investigation. This has, I think, only to be mentioned to be discarded as at once undesirable if for

the necessary

no

other

than that

co-operation and investigation. setting psychological In conclusion I would say that prison is a deterrent principally to those who do not need a deterrent. The majority of prisoners settle down in a more or less comfortable manner to the circumstances and routine in a comparatively short impracticable and compulsion is

not

for all

reason

MENTAL

WELFARE

45

time and this in my view shows the futility of the short sentences for most Something more is required; investigation and guidance?not necessarily deep psychological analysis, but something which is continued on release from prison in the form of probationary supervision,?this, of course, is !he method of the Borstal Association. There are many cases who will not return to prison

cases.

do not need mental investigation but often friendly talk and advice is of much assistance to them?they are those who do not normally need a deterrent but have for once made a mistake and yielded to temptation and circumstances.

?they

The

of

society must take priority over the interests of the problem as workers on the mental health side must be to forward the study of the individual delinquent and therebv be in a position to determine the best methods of dealing with him. adequate protection

individual;

our

contribution to the

Immature prophecy and over zealous enthusiasm will bring into disrepute and enshroud in scepticism new departures from established practice. The careful

worker, whether official

unofficial,

or

will

gradually adjust

his

perspective

as new

methods prove their worth. I have mentioned the side of

new

Criminal

Justice Bill obviously it

where it touches the mental

would not be proper for me intimately, but controversial aspects. I have indicated the general penal changes which have taken place in recent years and have followed the appreciation of the contribution of psychological medicine to the treatment of criminals. The our

to comment

problem on

its

most

more

psychological medicine are still somewhat fluid. It has, however, helped understanding of many of our cases although further study is necessary before its final place can be satisfactorily assigned. The future prospect is one of hopeful anticipation, which, to be realised, must be based on proved and sound foundations, and these can only be established by the unhesitating and liberal co-operation of all who are engaged in the care and treatment of the abnormal delinquent.

bases of us

to

a

better

Recent Penal Legislation in Relation to Mental Health Problems.

Recent Penal Legislation in Relation to Mental Health Problems. - PDF Download Free
4MB Sizes 1 Downloads 7 Views