DSTXXX10.1177/1932296813511749Journal of Diabetes Science and TechnologyDas et al
Letter to the Editor Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 2014, Vol. 8(1) 194–195 © 2014 Diabetes Technology Society Reprints and permissions: sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/1932296813511749 dst.sagepub.com
Evaluation of the Performance of a Novel Five-Level A1c Cellular Linearity Calibration Verification Kit
Kausik Das, PhD1, Stephanie M. Wigginton, BA1, and Joel M. Lechner, MS1 Keywords HbA1c, A1c, A1c Cellular Linearity, A1c control, diabetes diagnosis, A1c correlation
20 Level 5
16
Level 4
12
Level 3 8
Level 2 Level 1
4
Orhto Clinic Vitros
Roche Cobas 6000
Bio-Rad Variant II
Bio-Rad D10
Bio-Rad Variant II Turbo
Roche Cobas INTEGRA
Siemens-Dimension
Tosoh G7/G8
0 Abbott ARCHITECT System
Measuring hemoglobin A1c level in blood is one of the methods for diagnosing and monitoring diabetes.1,2 Nondiabetic A1c values usually vary in the 4.0-5.7% range, and diabetic A1c values vary above 6.5%.3 (A1c values are expressed according to National Glycohemoglobin Standard ization Program [NGSP] conventions.) However, unusually low (≤5%) or high (≥17%) A1c values have also been reported, although many of these are falsely influenced by medications or various rare hemoglobin traits.4,5 Therefore, validating the entire analytical range of the instrument is important to accurately address unusual cases. This range for the majority of A1c analyzers is usually 3.0-18.0%. Ideally, whole blood samples should be used as the verification material. However, rarity at extreme A1c values, impurity, and instability are major drawbacks for whole blood to be used as verification material. An alternative verification material based on stabilized blood with relevant analytical properties could better serve this purpose. Since hemoglobin A1c is an intracellular protein, its measurement involves lysis of red blood cells. Therefore, the presence of hemoglobin A1c within an intact cell is an important property for such reference material. In this article, the interinstrument correlation of such a reference material, Streck’s A1c-Cellular® Linearity calibration verification kit, is evaluated. This kit contains 5 levels that can be used in the same manner as a patient sample. To evaluate the interinstrument correlation, the A1c values for each instrument are averaged from 6 runs, across 4 lots, with data collected from 2 laboratories. The average A1c values for levels 1-5 are approximately 3.5%, 6.8%, 10.4%, 14.1%, and 17.9%. The coefficients of determination (R2) between the A1c values of the levels are greater than .998 for all tested instruments for multiple lots. To evaluate the interinstrument correlation, ±6.0% range of the target A1c values is applied according to CAP guideline or NGSP certification criteria.6 Figure 1 shows that for levels 2-5, nearly all A1c values for the tested instruments fall within ±6% of the respective target values. Comparable interinstrument coefficient of variation were observed for whole blood samples (2.3-6.9%) and A1c Cellular Linearity (3.3-4.1%; data not shown). The interinstrument bias (Tosoh G8 as reference) is comparable for whole blood sample and
Beckman Coulter UniCell DxC 600/800 Synchron
2014
A1c (%, NGSP)
11749
Figure 1. Interinstrument correlation of the 5-level A1c Cellular Linearity calibration verification kit. The A1c values are expressed in National Glycohemoglobin Standardization Program units. The shaded area represents the ±6% of the respective target A1c values for each level. The A1c values for each instrument are averaged from at least 6 runs, across 4 lots with data collected from 2 laboratories. Data obtained outside the instrument analytical ranges were excluded from the analysis.
A1c-Cellular Linearity in the corresponding A1c ranges (data not shown). The A1c values of Level 1 of A1c-Cellular Linearity on few instruments are outside the respective CAP acceptable range, which could perhaps be due to the high 1
Streck Inc, La Vista, NE, USA
Corresponding Author: Kausik Das, Research & Development Division, Streck Inc, 7002 S 109 St, La Vista, NE 68128, USA. Email: [email protected]
195
Das et al sensitivity of the instruments at their lower limits of detection, a matrix effect from the linearity material, or a combination of both. The stability studies show that the A1c values of this linearity/calibration verification kit are stable for 105 days at 6°C, in which the A1c values of the levels 1-5 varied within ±2 SD range (data not shown). In conclusion, the A1c values of the 5-level A1c Cellular Linearity calibration verification kit across several analyzers are within CAP-accepted guideline and NGSP certification. In addition, presence of hemoglobin A1c within intact red cells allows this reference material to test all analytical steps. Abbreviation NGSP, National Glycohemoglobin Standardization Program.
Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge Gary Krzyzanowski and Justyna Tesmer, Streck Inc.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests The author(s) declared the following potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: Kausik Das, Stephanie M. Wigginton, and Joel M. Lechner are employees of Streck Inc.
Funding The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: The research is funded by Streck Inc.
References 1. Use of glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) in the diagnosis of diabetes mellitus. Abbreviated report of a WHO consultation. www.who.int/diabetes/publications/report-hba1c_2011.pdf. Accessed September 16, 2013. 2. Diagnosing diagnosis and prediabetes—American Diabetes Association. http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-basics/diagnosis/. Accessed September 27, 2013. 3. Barrot A, Dupuy AM, Badiou S, Bargnoux AS, Cristol JP. Evaluation of three turbidimetric assays for automated determination of hemoglobin A1c. Clin Lab. 2012;58:1171-1177. 4. Gross BM, Cross LB, Foard JC, Wood YA. Falsely low hemoglobin A1c levels in a patient receiving ribavirin and peginterferon alfa-2b for hepatitis C. Pharmacotherapy. 2009;29:121-123. 5. Zhu Y, Williams LM. Falsely elevated hemoglobin A1c due to S-β+-thalassemia interference in Bio-Rad Variant II Turbo HbA1c assay. Clin Chim Acta. 2009;409:18-20. 6. NGSP news: new NGSP certification criteria beginning Jan. 2014. http://www.ngsp.org/news.asp/. Accessed September 27, 2013.
Letter to the Editor Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology 2014, Vol. 8(1) 194–195 © 2014 Diabetes Technology Society Reprints and permissions: sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav DOI: 10.1177/1932296813511749 dst.sagepub.com
Evaluation of the Performance of a Novel Five-Level A1c Cellular Linearity Calibration Verification Kit
Kausik Das, PhD1, Stephanie M. Wigginton, BA1, and Joel M. Lechner, MS1 Keywords HbA1c, A1c, A1c Cellular Linearity, A1c control, diabetes diagnosis, A1c correlation
20 Level 5
16
Level 4
12
Level 3 8
Level 2 Level 1
4
Orhto Clinic Vitros
Roche Cobas 6000
Bio-Rad Variant II
Bio-Rad D10
Bio-Rad Variant II Turbo
Roche Cobas INTEGRA
Siemens-Dimension
Tosoh G7/G8
0 Abbott ARCHITECT System
Measuring hemoglobin A1c level in blood is one of the methods for diagnosing and monitoring diabetes.1,2 Nondiabetic A1c values usually vary in the 4.0-5.7% range, and diabetic A1c values vary above 6.5%.3 (A1c values are expressed according to National Glycohemoglobin Standard ization Program [NGSP] conventions.) However, unusually low (≤5%) or high (≥17%) A1c values have also been reported, although many of these are falsely influenced by medications or various rare hemoglobin traits.4,5 Therefore, validating the entire analytical range of the instrument is important to accurately address unusual cases. This range for the majority of A1c analyzers is usually 3.0-18.0%. Ideally, whole blood samples should be used as the verification material. However, rarity at extreme A1c values, impurity, and instability are major drawbacks for whole blood to be used as verification material. An alternative verification material based on stabilized blood with relevant analytical properties could better serve this purpose. Since hemoglobin A1c is an intracellular protein, its measurement involves lysis of red blood cells. Therefore, the presence of hemoglobin A1c within an intact cell is an important property for such reference material. In this article, the interinstrument correlation of such a reference material, Streck’s A1c-Cellular® Linearity calibration verification kit, is evaluated. This kit contains 5 levels that can be used in the same manner as a patient sample. To evaluate the interinstrument correlation, the A1c values for each instrument are averaged from 6 runs, across 4 lots, with data collected from 2 laboratories. The average A1c values for levels 1-5 are approximately 3.5%, 6.8%, 10.4%, 14.1%, and 17.9%. The coefficients of determination (R2) between the A1c values of the levels are greater than .998 for all tested instruments for multiple lots. To evaluate the interinstrument correlation, ±6.0% range of the target A1c values is applied according to CAP guideline or NGSP certification criteria.6 Figure 1 shows that for levels 2-5, nearly all A1c values for the tested instruments fall within ±6% of the respective target values. Comparable interinstrument coefficient of variation were observed for whole blood samples (2.3-6.9%) and A1c Cellular Linearity (3.3-4.1%; data not shown). The interinstrument bias (Tosoh G8 as reference) is comparable for whole blood sample and
Beckman Coulter UniCell DxC 600/800 Synchron
2014
A1c (%, NGSP)
11749
Figure 1. Interinstrument correlation of the 5-level A1c Cellular Linearity calibration verification kit. The A1c values are expressed in National Glycohemoglobin Standardization Program units. The shaded area represents the ±6% of the respective target A1c values for each level. The A1c values for each instrument are averaged from at least 6 runs, across 4 lots with data collected from 2 laboratories. Data obtained outside the instrument analytical ranges were excluded from the analysis.
A1c-Cellular Linearity in the corresponding A1c ranges (data not shown). The A1c values of Level 1 of A1c-Cellular Linearity on few instruments are outside the respective CAP acceptable range, which could perhaps be due to the high 1
Streck Inc, La Vista, NE, USA
Corresponding Author: Kausik Das, Research & Development Division, Streck Inc, 7002 S 109 St, La Vista, NE 68128, USA. Email: [email protected]
195
Das et al sensitivity of the instruments at their lower limits of detection, a matrix effect from the linearity material, or a combination of both. The stability studies show that the A1c values of this linearity/calibration verification kit are stable for 105 days at 6°C, in which the A1c values of the levels 1-5 varied within ±2 SD range (data not shown). In conclusion, the A1c values of the 5-level A1c Cellular Linearity calibration verification kit across several analyzers are within CAP-accepted guideline and NGSP certification. In addition, presence of hemoglobin A1c within intact red cells allows this reference material to test all analytical steps. Abbreviation NGSP, National Glycohemoglobin Standardization Program.
Acknowledgments The authors acknowledge Gary Krzyzanowski and Justyna Tesmer, Streck Inc.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests The author(s) declared the following potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: Kausik Das, Stephanie M. Wigginton, and Joel M. Lechner are employees of Streck Inc.
Funding The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: The research is funded by Streck Inc.
References 1. Use of glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) in the diagnosis of diabetes mellitus. Abbreviated report of a WHO consultation. www.who.int/diabetes/publications/report-hba1c_2011.pdf. Accessed September 16, 2013. 2. Diagnosing diagnosis and prediabetes—American Diabetes Association. http://www.diabetes.org/diabetes-basics/diagnosis/. Accessed September 27, 2013. 3. Barrot A, Dupuy AM, Badiou S, Bargnoux AS, Cristol JP. Evaluation of three turbidimetric assays for automated determination of hemoglobin A1c. Clin Lab. 2012;58:1171-1177. 4. Gross BM, Cross LB, Foard JC, Wood YA. Falsely low hemoglobin A1c levels in a patient receiving ribavirin and peginterferon alfa-2b for hepatitis C. Pharmacotherapy. 2009;29:121-123. 5. Zhu Y, Williams LM. Falsely elevated hemoglobin A1c due to S-β+-thalassemia interference in Bio-Rad Variant II Turbo HbA1c assay. Clin Chim Acta. 2009;409:18-20. 6. NGSP news: new NGSP certification criteria beginning Jan. 2014. http://www.ngsp.org/news.asp/. Accessed September 27, 2013.
